Home › Personality Types › Growth Mindset: What It Is and What the Evidence Shows

Growth Mindset: What It Is, What Got Distorted, and What the Evidence Actually Shows

The belief that ability can be developed rather than issued at birth, and the different response to failure that follows from it. One of the most influential ideas in modern psychology, and one of the most oversold.

6 sources cited12 min read
Growth mindset: a woodworker sands a chair leg at her bench beside a row of earlier attempts running from rough to finished.

In short

A growth mindset is the belief that ability, including intelligence, can be developed through effort, strategy and help from others; its opposite, a fixed mindset, treats ability as something you either have or do not. Carol Dweck's research found that the two beliefs predict different responses to difficulty: people holding a growth view tend to treat a setback as information, while people holding a fixed view tend to treat it as a verdict. The evidence behind the idea is more mixed than its popularity suggests, with small average effects in schools that are larger for students who are struggling. Psychology.com's free Growth Mindset Test reports where your own beliefs currently sit.

Proposed by
Carol Dweck and colleagues, from the 1980s onward
The claim
Beliefs about whether ability is fixed change the response to failure
Research name
Implicit theories of intelligence
Average effect in schools
Small, and larger for students who are struggling
Common misreading
That praising effort is the intervention
Test
Growth Mindset Test

What a growth mindset is

A growth mindset is the belief that abilities are built rather than issued: that intelligence, skill and talent can change substantially with effort, better strategies and help from other people. A fixed mindset is the belief that they are largely set, so that what you can do now is a fair indication of what you will ever be able to do.

The idea is not really about optimism. It is about what a difficulty means. If ability is developable, then struggling with something hard is what learning feels like, and a bad result is information about the approach. If ability is fixed, then struggling is evidence about the limit, and a bad result is a measurement of you. Those two readings of the same afternoon lead to different behavior over the following month.

Researchers call these beliefs implicit theories of intelligence, which is a more accurate name than mindset because they are usually unexamined. Most people have never stated their theory of ability to themselves. It shows up instead in what they avoid, how they explain a failure, and whether they ask for feedback they might not enjoy.

What Dweck proposed, and what the original studies showed

Carol Dweck's work grew out of research on why some people give up quickly after failure and others do not, when their ability is comparable. Her account was that the difference lies in what the failure is taken to mean, and that this follows from a belief about whether ability is the kind of thing that changes.

The best known early study is Mueller and Dweck's 1998 series. Children who were praised for intelligence after succeeding at a task, rather than for effort, went on to choose easier tasks afterward, showed less persistence and enjoyment when the problems got harder, and performed worse on a later set. Some also misrepresented their scores to a stranger. The finding was that a particular kind of praise can install a fixed reading of ability and that the cost shows up when the work gets difficult.

Blackwell, Trzesniewski and Dweck's 2007 study followed students across the transition to junior high, a point where grades commonly drop. Students holding a growth view of intelligence pulled ahead over two years; those holding a fixed view flattened. The same paper reported an intervention teaching the malleability of intelligence, which improved motivation and arrested the decline in grades relative to a control group.

Those are real findings, and they are the sturdy base of the idea. What happened next is the complicated part.

How the idea reached schools, and what got distorted

Few psychological ideas have traveled as fast. Mindset became posters, assemblies, teacher training, corporate workshops and a vocabulary that reached far beyond the research it came from. Dweck herself has written about the distortions, describing a version she called the false growth mindset: the claim of holding one without the practice behind it.

Three distortions did most of the damage. The first was treating effort praise as the whole intervention. Telling a student they worked hard, when they worked hard on the wrong approach and got nowhere, is not a growth mindset. It is a consolation prize, and students notice. The original point was that effort, strategy and help together move ability, which means praising effort that was not paired with a change of strategy misses the mechanism entirely.

The second was the binary. The posters put people into two camps, growth or fixed, when the research describes beliefs that vary by domain and by situation. Almost everybody holds a growth view of something and a fixed view of something else, and the fixed one tends to appear under stress, after criticism, or in the one subject they decided they were bad at when they were nine.

The third, and the most serious, was using mindset to explain away a system's failures. If a school is underfunded, understaffed and teaching to a test, telling the students their beliefs about intelligence are the problem shifts the responsibility to the people with the least power in the building. That critique has been made repeatedly by education researchers, and it is fair.

What the meta-analyses actually found

This is the part most pages about growth mindset leave out. Sisk and colleagues' 2018 paper ran two meta-analyses. The first, covering 273 effect sizes from nearly 366,000 people, found an average correlation between mindset and academic achievement of .10, which is very weak. Over half of the individual effect sizes, 157 of 273, were not significantly different from zero, and sixteen pointed the other way.

The second meta-analysis looked at whether mindset interventions improve achievement. Across 43 effect sizes from more than 57,000 participants, the average effect was 0.08 standard deviations, with 37 of the 43 effects not significantly different from zero. Two subgroups did better: students from low socioeconomic households showed an average effect of 0.34, resting on seven effect sizes, and students classified as high academic risk showed 0.19, a borderline result resting on eight, so neither is a clean subgroup finding. For middle-class and upper-class students the effect was effectively nothing.

Yeager and colleagues' 2019 study in Nature was the largest and best designed test of the question: a short online intervention delivered to more than 12,000 ninth graders across a nationally representative sample of 65 United States high schools. It raised grades among lower-achieving students by about a tenth of a grade point in core subjects and increased enrollment in advanced math. It also found that the effect depended on the school: where peer norms did not support taking on challenge, the intervention did not take.

The two large reviews published in 2023 disagree with each other, which is worth knowing rather than hiding. Macnamara and Burgoyne concluded that the apparent effects of these interventions on achievement most likely come from weak study design, flawed reporting and bias. Burnette and colleagues, reviewing an overlapping literature in the same journal issue, found a small effect on achievement, about 0.14 standard deviations, when well-delivered interventions reached the students expected to benefit most, with wide variation from one intervention to the next.

What still holds up

Strip away the claims that did not survive and something solid is left. Ability in most domains really is more developable than people assume, which is not a mindset finding but a learning one, supported by decades of research on deliberate practice and skill acquisition. Believing an untrue thing about your own ceiling has costs, and that belief is open to evidence.

The behavioral chain Dweck described also holds up better than the intervention results do. People who read difficulty as information rather than as a verdict do take on harder work, do ask for feedback more readily, and do recover from setbacks faster. What the meta-analyses question is whether a brief classroom exercise can change that chain for the average student, not whether the chain exists.

And the subgroup pattern is itself a finding, not a consolation. The benefit that shows up belongs to students who are struggling or disadvantaged, and mindset theory explains it as a fixed belief doing the most damage there: where a student has concluded they are not a math person, or that people like them do not succeed here. That is a narrower and more useful claim than the one on the posters, and it is the one the national trial points to.

How to use it on yourself anyway

The research is about average effects on groups of students, mostly adolescents, in school settings. An adult asking what to do with the idea is asking a different question, and the honest answer is that mindset is useful as a prompt rather than as a program. Four moves do most of the work.

Pick one skill and get evidence. The most persuasive argument against a fixed belief is not an argument. It is six weeks of deliberate practice at something you were bad at, with a record of where you started. A belief about your own ceiling is open to evidence, and a record you produced yourself is harder to argue with than a paragraph about malleable ability.

Change the explanation you give after a bad result. The useful question after failing at something is not whether you are good at it but which part broke: the preparation, the approach, the conditions or the amount of practice. That is an attribution habit, it is trainable, and it overlaps with the research on locus of control, which asks a closely related question about what you think causes outcomes.

Ask for the feedback you do not want, in small doses. A fixed reading of ability makes criticism feel like a measurement, so people with it avoid exactly the information that would help them improve. Starting with one specific question to one person you trust is more effective than a resolution to be open to feedback.

And pair effort with strategy. Effort alone plateaus, and when it does, a person who has been told effort is the answer concludes the fixed view was right all along. The strongest version of this idea is persistence plus a willingness to change the approach, which is also how our test's own result screen frames it.

Growth mindset at work

Most of the evidence is about classrooms, so claims about workplaces should be made carefully. What transfers reasonably is the individual-level logic: people who believe skills are developable are more likely to take on stretch assignments, seek feedback, and persist through the unpleasant middle of learning something new.

What transfers badly is the organizational version. A company announcing that it has a growth mindset while still promoting on the basis of apparent natural talent, punishing visible failure and rewarding the appearance of effortless competence has changed its vocabulary and nothing else. Employees read the incentives, not the posters.

If you manage people, the practical version is narrow and does work: describe the development path for a skill rather than the person's level, give feedback on strategy rather than on aptitude, and make it safe to report that something is not working early. None of that requires anyone to believe anything in particular about intelligence.

Common misconceptions

That a growth mindset means anyone can become anything. It does not, and Dweck has never claimed it. Abilities differ, starting points differ, and circumstances constrain what is reachable. The claim is about the degree to which ability can develop, not about the absence of limits.

That praising effort is the intervention. Praising effort that produced nothing teaches a student that effort is what you get praised for when you cannot be praised for results. Feedback that works names the strategy, the specific improvement, or the next thing to try.

That you are either a growth or a fixed person. Beliefs are domain-specific and move with the situation. Most people hold both, and the fixed one surfaces in a predictable trigger, usually criticism, comparison or a subject they wrote themselves off in long ago.

That having the right mindset is enough. It is one modest ingredient among many: teaching quality, sleep, time, money, support and strategy all matter more. Treating a mindset as the deciding factor is how an idea about belief becomes a way of blaming people for their circumstances.

How to find where your beliefs sit

Psychology.com's free Growth Mindset Test takes a few minutes and places your answers in one of four bands, from a strong fixed lean through a genuinely mixed pattern to a strong growth view. Eight of its 14 statements are adapted from Dweck's published intelligence-belief items and six are our own statements about effort, and the result is a self-assessment for reflection, not a measurement of your potential.

Most people land in the middle, which is the honest place to be and the most useful result to work with. A mixed score usually means the fixed beliefs are clustered: in one subject, one skill, or one situation where comparison is sharpest. Finding the cluster is worth more than the overall band.

If you want the two patterns laid out side by side, with the self-talk that gives each away and the moves that shift a response in the moment, the growth mindset vs fixed mindset page is the practical companion to this one. An optional in-depth report is available on the result screen for readers who want a longer write-up.

FeatureWhat the evidence supportsWhat the slogan claims
Size of the effectSmall on average, larger for struggling studentsA transformation for everyone
Who benefits mostStudents facing academic risk or disadvantageAll students equally
What the intervention isChanging what a setback is taken to meanPraising effort
Shape of the beliefDomain-specific and situationalTwo kinds of people
What ability can doDevelop substantially, within real limitsBecome anything
Where responsibility sitsOne modest ingredient among teaching, time and supportWith the learner's attitude

Key takeaways

  • A growth mindset is the belief that ability can be developed; a fixed mindset treats it as largely set. The difference shows in what a setback is taken to mean.
  • The original studies are real: intelligence praise reduced persistence in Mueller and Dweck's 1998 experiments, and growth beliefs tracked better grade trajectories across a school transition.
  • The average effects are small. A meta-analysis of 273 effects found a correlation of .10 between mindset and achievement, and interventions averaged 0.08 standard deviations.
  • In the 2018 meta-analysis interventions did best for low-income students and students at high academic risk: an effect of 0.34 for low-income students, a borderline 0.19 for students at high academic risk, and effectively zero for well-off students.
  • Three distortions did the damage: effort praise as a slogan, a false binary between two kinds of people, and using student beliefs to explain a system's failures.
  • For an individual, the usable version is specific practice with a record, better attributions after failure, requested feedback, and effort paired with a change of strategy.

Where do your beliefs about ability sit?

The free Growth Mindset Test places your answers on a four-band scale and shows which beliefs are doing the talking.

Take the free Growth Mindset Test

Cite this source

Fontane Pennock, S. (2026, November 8). Growth Mindset: What It Is and What the Evidence Shows. Psychology.com. https://psychology.com/types/growth-mindset

Frequently asked questions

What is a growth mindset?

The belief that ability, including intelligence, can be developed through effort, better strategies and help from others. The opposite, a fixed mindset, treats ability as largely set. The practical difference is what a setback is taken to mean: information about the approach, or a verdict about the person. Carol Dweck's research calls these implicit theories of intelligence.

Does growth mindset actually work?

Modestly, and mostly for specific groups. A meta-analysis of 43 intervention effects found an average of 0.08 standard deviations, with most individual effects not significantly different from zero. The exceptions matter: 0.34 for students from low-income households, and a borderline 0.19 for students at high academic risk. For well-off students the average effect was effectively zero.

Who came up with growth mindset?

Carol Dweck, a psychologist whose research on responses to failure began in the 1980s and reached a general audience with Mindset in 2006. The underlying research program is on implicit theories of intelligence, developed with colleagues including Claudia Mueller, Lisa Blackwell and Kali Trzesniewski, and later tested at national scale with David Yeager.

Does praising effort create a growth mindset?

Not on its own, and this is the most common misreading. Mueller and Dweck's 1998 experiments showed that children praised for intelligence after a success chose easier tasks afterward and gave up sooner, which is where the advice to praise effort instead came from. What the research describes is a belief that effort, better strategy and help together move ability. Praising effort that produced nothing teaches a student that effort is the consolation prize for not being praised for the result.

Is growth mindset just positive thinking?

No, and the confusion is why so many classroom versions failed. It is not about feeling good about a bad result. It is about attributing the result to something changeable: preparation, strategy, practice or conditions. Effort without a change of approach plateaus, and the strongest version of the idea is persistence paired with a willingness to try a different method.

Can an adult change their mindset?

Beliefs about ability move when experience contradicts them, which makes demonstration more effective than persuasion. The reliable method is to pick one skill you believe you are bad at, practice deliberately for a fixed period, and keep a record of where you started. Reading about malleable ability changes less than proving it to yourself once.

Why do researchers criticize growth mindset?

On three grounds: the average effects are much smaller than the popular claims, the school versions often reduced to effort praise that does not match the mechanism, and the idea has been used to place responsibility for a system's failures on students' beliefs. A 2023 review concluded that apparent intervention effects owe a lot to weak study designs and reporting bias.

Related types

References

  1. Mueller CM, Dweck CS. Praise for intelligence can undermine children's motivation and performance. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. 1998;75(1):33-52. doi.org
  2. Blackwell LS, Trzesniewski KH, Dweck CS. Implicit theories of intelligence predict achievement across an adolescent transition: A longitudinal study and an intervention. Child Development. 2007;78(1):246-263. doi.org
  3. Sisk VF, Burgoyne AP, Sun J, Butler JL, Macnamara BN. To what extent and under which circumstances are growth mind-sets important to academic achievement? Two meta-analyses. Psychological Science. 2018;29(4):549-571. doi.org
  4. Yeager DS, Hanselman P, Walton GM, et al. A national experiment reveals where a growth mindset improves achievement. Nature. 2019;573(7774):364-369. doi.org
  5. Macnamara BN, Burgoyne AP. Do growth mindset interventions impact students' academic achievement? A systematic review and meta-analysis with recommendations for best practices. Psychological Bulletin. 2023;149(3-4):133-173. doi.org
  6. Burnette JL, Billingsley J, Banks GC, et al. A systematic review and meta-analysis of growth mindset interventions: For whom, how, and why might such interventions work? Psychological Bulletin. 2023;149(3-4):174-205. doi.org
Important: A personality type, attachment style, or result pattern is an educational way of describing tendencies, not a diagnosis, a fixed identity, or a substitute for professional care. If you are struggling, reach out to a licensed mental-health professional.