In short
Multiple intelligences is Howard Gardner's 1983 proposal that human ability comes in several relatively independent kinds rather than one general capacity. He originally described seven, later added a naturalist intelligence to make eight, and treated a ninth, existential intelligence, as unresolved because the evidence he required for it was missing. The theory spread through education faster than almost any idea in modern psychology, and it has not been supported by the research that followed: when the domains have been measured, they correlate rather than standing independent, no validated instrument for them exists, and the learning-styles teaching practice built on top of the idea has repeatedly failed to work. Psychology.com's Multiple Intelligences Test is a self-reflection exercise based on the theory, not a validated measure, and it says so.
- Proposed by
- Howard Gardner, Frames of Mind, 1983
- The count
- Seven originally, eight after naturalist was added
- The ninth
- Existential, discussed and never formally added
- Evidence status
- A framework, not a measured set of abilities
- Main finding against it
- The domains correlate instead of standing independent
- Test
- Multiple Intelligences Test
The argument Gardner was making
Howard Gardner's target in Frames of Mind, published in 1983, was the practice of summarizing a mind in a single number. He was not arguing that intelligence tests measure nothing. He was arguing that a test built around language and logic names only a narrow slice of human competence, and that the slice it names had come to define what counted as being smart at all.
His alternative was to treat ability as a set of relatively independent capacities, each with its own developmental course, its own expert end state and its own way of going wrong. A person could be formidable in one and ordinary in another, and no single figure could represent that. He called them intelligences rather than talents on purpose, because the word talent was precisely how the school system had been dismissing them.
Read as a protest about what schools value, the argument landed and is still worth making. Read as a claim about the structure of measured ability, it ran into trouble almost immediately, and keeping those two readings apart is the only way to discuss this topic honestly.
The eight he defended
Gardner began with seven and later added naturalist, which is the count his own writing has used since. Our Multiple Intelligences Test reports all eight because the theory treats most people as a genuine blend rather than one single type.
- Linguistic: thinking in words. Writing, reading, storytelling, and explaining a complicated idea so someone else can follow it.
- Logical-mathematical: thinking in patterns, numbers and step-by-step reasoning, and noticing when an explanation does not hold together.
- Spatial: thinking in pictures. Visualizing how things fit, reading a map easily, rehearsing a layout before anything is moved.
- Bodily-kinesthetic: thinking through movement. Hands-on skill, physical coordination, learning a movement faster by doing it than by reading it.
- Musical: thinking in rhythm and sound. Sensitivity to pitch, timing and pattern, with or without formal training.
- Interpersonal: reading and relating to other people. Noticing moods and motives, and responding in a way that works.
- Intrapersonal: self-understanding. Reflecting accurately on your own feelings, motivations and values, and planning from them.
- Naturalist: noticing and classifying patterns in the living world, from plant species to weather to the behavior of animals.
The list is not arbitrary. Gardner set out eight criteria that a candidate had to satisfy before he would call it an intelligence, among them that it could be knocked out selectively by brain damage, that prodigies and savants existed in it, that it had an identifiable core set of operations, that it showed a distinct developmental path toward a recognizable expert performance, that it had a plausible evolutionary history, and that it could be encoded in a symbol system. Having explicit criteria is one of the genuinely strong features of the theory, because it makes the list arguable rather than a matter of taste.
The ninth, and why it stayed out
Search results for this topic are full of nine intelligences, and the ninth is existential: the capacity to ask large questions about meaning, life and death. Gardner discussed it at length in Intelligence Reframed in 1999, alongside the naturalist intelligence he did add, and he declined to promote it.
His reason was his own criteria. He has said since that he still wants more evidence for it, and that for now he would put the count at eight and a half, because no region of the brain has been identified as dedicated to those questions, while the evidence for the naturalist intelligence does meet his bar. His own current materials list eight and omit existential entirely.
That is a small story with a large moral. The best-known thing about this theory in popular circulation, the ninth intelligence, is something its author considered and rejected on evidential grounds. Anyone presenting nine as the settled list is describing the internet rather than Gardner.
Why education adopted it so fast
The uptake was extraordinary. Within a decade of publication the theory was in teacher training, curriculum design, classroom posters and school mission statements across much of the English-speaking world, far ahead of any evidence that it worked.
Three things explain the speed. It arrived with a solution to a real problem, which was a generation of pupils written off by a narrow measure. It was immediately actionable, because a teacher could do something with it on Monday morning. And it flattered nobody's enemy: every child has a strength somewhere on a list of eight, which is a far better message to send home than a percentile.
None of those are reasons to believe something, and the gap between adoption and evidence is the central fact in this topic's history. The idea won the classroom without winning the laboratory, and the research of the two decades since has not changed much in the classroom.
What the research actually found
The strongest direct test came from Beth Visser, Michael Ashton and Philip Vernon in 2006. They operationalized eight of the intelligences, selected two tests for each, and administered the set to 200 adults. Factor analysis produced a large general factor with substantial loadings for the tests of purely cognitive abilities, linguistic, logical-mathematical, spatial, naturalistic and interpersonal, and lower loadings for the others, especially bodily-kinesthetic.
That result cuts against the independence claim, which is the load-bearing part of the theory: abilities that correlate this strongly are not separate intelligences in the sense Gardner argued for, they look like the broad abilities of an ordinary hierarchical model. The same study did find weak non-general associations within most domains, which offers modest support for the domains being coherent groupings. Both halves of that finding are worth stating.
The broader criticism came from Lynn Waterhouse in a 2006 review in Educational Psychologist, which concluded that there were no published studies validating multiple intelligences theory as a measurement model. More than two decades after publication, no instrument existed that had been shown to measure eight separable intelligences, which for a theory about distinct abilities is a serious absence.
Gardner and Seana Moran replied in the same issue, arguing that the theory was a reframing of what counts as intelligence rather than a psychometric model, that it was never intended to be captured by paper-and-pencil tests, and that the evidence behind it was the convergence of neuropsychological, developmental and cross-cultural findings on his criteria rather than factor analysis. He has also argued that tests built to measure his intelligences import too much verbal and logical content to measure anything else.
The learning-styles problem
The practice that grew out of the theory was teaching to a pupil's strongest intelligence: present material visually to a visual learner, kinesthetically to a kinesthetic one. This is sometimes called the meshing hypothesis, and it is the single most widely implemented claim in modern education.
It does not survive testing. A 2008 review by Harold Pashler, Mark McDaniel, Doug Rohrer and Robert Bjork found that almost no studies had used the design capable of testing it, which requires assigning learners with different styles to different instruction and showing that each does best with their own match. Of the few studies with an adequate design, the results contradicted the hypothesis.
It is worth being precise about what fails here. People do have preferences, and preferences are real. What fails is the claim that matching instruction to a preference improves learning. Gardner has himself distanced the theory from learning styles, pointing out that an intelligence is a capacity and a style is a habit of approach, and that the two were conflated by practitioners rather than by him.
What is worth keeping
Something real survives the critique, and it is not nothing. The protest against a single number as a summary of a person was correct, and the field has moved toward it: every major battery now reports a profile of domain scores precisely because one figure hides too much.
The respect for non-academic ability also survives. Musical skill, physical craft, reading a room and knowing your own mind are genuine competences that matter enormously in a life and are invisible to a reasoning test. You do not need them to be separate intelligences for that to be true, and treating them as worth developing is good advice regardless of how the factor analysis comes out.
What does not survive is the use of the framework as a verdict on what someone is. A pupil labeled a kinesthetic learner and steered away from reading has been harmed by a label, which is the same harm the theory was written to prevent.
Multiple intelligences compared with the general-factor view
The two positions are often presented as a fight, and the honest picture is narrower than that. They disagree about two things. The first is independence: Gardner's theory requires the domains to stand substantially apart, while the hierarchical model predicts that they will correlate, which is what happens whenever anyone measures them. The second is scope: the general-factor view counts only cognitive domains as intelligence, while Gardner counts musical, physical and personal competence too.
They agree on more than the argument suggests. Both hold that one number is a poor summary of a person, which is why modern batteries report a set of index scores rather than a single figure. Both recognize separate visual and auditory domains. The difference is that the hierarchical model arrived there from factor analysis of test data and can point to reliable instruments, while the multiple intelligences account arrived there from criteria about brain damage, prodigies, development and culture, and has no validated instrument behind it.
What does not survive the comparison is any suggestion that the research is split down the middle. On the measurement question specifically, the evidence runs one way, and a page that implied otherwise would be flattering the reader rather than informing them.
What our test can and cannot tell you
Psychology.com's Multiple Intelligences Test is 40 statements about how you prefer to think, learn and work, scored across all eight dimensions. It names your top two as your strongest areas and shows the whole profile, because most people are a genuine blend. It is described on the test itself as a self-reflection exercise based on Gardner's theory rather than a validated instrument, and that description is accurate.
What it measures is self-reported preference and comfort, not measured ability. A high linguistic score means you say you are drawn to and comfortable with words, which is useful information about where you will enjoy spending effort. It does not mean a vocabulary test would place you highly, and someone scoring lower there can be a precise and effective writer in the areas they care about.
Used that way the result is genuinely worth having. It points at the kinds of work and learning you are likely to find energizing, which is a reasonable thing to know when choosing a course, a hobby or how to approach a problem. Used as a verdict on your capabilities, it would be claiming something neither the test nor the theory behind it can support. An optional in-depth report is available if you want a longer write-up of your profile.
What the research says
The plain statement is that multiple intelligences is a framework for thinking about human ability rather than a measured set of abilities. It has explicit criteria, a serious argument behind it and a real influence on how schools talk about children. It does not have a validated instrument, and the one substantial attempt to measure its domains found them correlating with each other rather than standing apart.
The better-evidenced alternative is the hierarchical model that intelligence research converged on, in which narrow skills group into broad abilities and the broad abilities are positively correlated. That model does recognize separate domains, including visual processing and auditory processing, which covers some of Gardner's ground with evidence behind it. What it does not do is treat musical or bodily skill as intelligences, which is the disagreement in a sentence.
So read the theory as an argument about value, where it is strong, rather than as a map of the mind, where it is not. And read any multiple intelligences result, including ours, as a description of what you are drawn to rather than a measurement of what you can do.
| Feature | Multiple intelligences view | General-factor view |
|---|---|---|
| Core claim | Several relatively independent kinds of ability | Many abilities, all positively correlated |
| What counts as intelligence | Musical, bodily and personal domains included | Cognitive domains only |
| Basis of the evidence | Convergence of neuropsychology, development and culture on stated criteria | Factor analysis of test scores across many samples |
| Measurement | No validated instrument exists | Highly reliable batteries in clinical use |
| When domains are measured | Predicts they stand apart | Predicts they correlate, which is what is found |
| Prediction of outcomes | Not established | Modest group-level links to education and occupation |
| Practical use in schools | Widely adopted, poorly supported | Used in assessment, rarely in teaching method |
| Where it is strongest | As an argument about what schools should value | As a description of how test performance is organized |
Key takeaways
- Gardner proposed in 1983 that ability comes in several relatively independent kinds, against the practice of summarizing a mind with one number, and set eight explicit criteria for calling something an intelligence.
- He described seven originally and later added naturalist to make eight; the widely cited ninth, existential intelligence, is one he discussed and declined to add because the brain evidence his criteria require was missing.
- Education adopted the theory within a decade of publication, far ahead of any evidence that teaching from it worked.
- The strongest direct test, on 200 adults with two tests per intelligence, found a large general factor with substantial loadings for the cognitive domains, which undercuts the independence claim while giving modest support to the domains as coherent groupings.
- No validated instrument measuring eight separable intelligences exists, and the learning-styles practice built on the idea failed in the few studies designed well enough to test it.
- Our Multiple Intelligences Test measures self-reported preference and comfort, not ability, and is a self-reflection exercise rather than a validated measure.
See your own profile across the eight
Our free Multiple Intelligences Test is 40 statements and shows where your preferences sit across all eight dimensions, with an honest note on what the research supports.
Cite this source
Fontane Pennock, S. (2026, November 8). Gardner's Multiple Intelligences Explained. Psychology.com. https://psychology.com/types/gardners-multiple-intelligences
Frequently asked questions
What is the theory of multiple intelligences?
Howard Gardner's 1983 proposal that human ability comes in several relatively independent kinds rather than one general capacity. He defined eight: linguistic, logical-mathematical, spatial, bodily-kinesthetic, musical, interpersonal, intrapersonal and naturalist. He also set eight criteria a candidate had to meet before he would call it an intelligence, which is what keeps the list arguable rather than a matter of preference.
Are there 8 or 9 multiple intelligences?
Eight, on Gardner's own account. The ninth, existential intelligence, is a candidate he discussed in Intelligence Reframed in 1999 and declined to add; he has since described the count as eight and a half, because no region of the brain has been identified as dedicated to those questions. His current materials list eight and omit it.
Is multiple intelligences theory proven?
No. It is a framework rather than a measured set of abilities. No validated instrument exists for the eight domains, and the main attempt to measure them found them correlating with a general factor rather than standing independent. Gardner's reply is that the theory was never a psychometric model, which is a fair defense of his intent and also an acknowledgment that the measurement evidence is absent.
What is the main criticism of multiple intelligences?
That the proposed intelligences are not independent. When eight of them were operationalized and given to 200 adults, the purely cognitive ones loaded substantially on a single general factor. A 2006 review also found no published studies validating the theory as a measurement model. A separate criticism is that it has been conflated with learning styles, which do not work as advertised.
Does teaching to a child's strongest intelligence work?
The evidence says no. The claim that matching instruction to a learner's preferred style improves learning requires a specific study design to test it, and a 2008 review found almost no studies had used that design. Among the few that had, the results contradicted the claim. Preferences are real; the benefit of teaching to them is not established.
What is the difference between multiple intelligences and IQ?
An IQ score summarizes performance on reasoning, knowledge, memory and speed tasks against a reference group. Multiple intelligences is a wider list that includes musical, physical and personal domains and claims they are relatively independent. The practical difference is measurement: IQ batteries are reliable instruments with reference data, and no equivalent exists for the eight intelligences.
What does your Multiple Intelligences Test actually measure?
Self-reported preference and comfort across the eight dimensions, from 40 statements about how you like to think, learn and work. It names your top two and shows all eight, because most people are a blend. It is a self-reflection exercise based on the theory, not a validated instrument, so treat a high score as a sign of what energizes you rather than a measurement of ability.
Related types
References
- Gardner H. Frames of Mind: The Theory of Multiple Intelligences. Basic Books; 1983. openlibrary.org
- Gardner H. Intelligence Reframed: Multiple Intelligences for the 21st Century. Basic Books; 1999. (Where naturalist is added and existential intelligence is discussed without being added.) openlibrary.org
- Visser BA, Ashton MC, Vernon PA. Beyond g: Putting multiple intelligences theory to the test. Intelligence. 2006;34(5):487-502. doi.org
- Waterhouse L. Multiple Intelligences, the Mozart Effect, and Emotional Intelligence: A Critical Review. Educational Psychologist. 2006;41(4):207-225. doi.org
- Gardner H, Moran S. The Science of Multiple Intelligences Theory: A Response to Lynn Waterhouse. Educational Psychologist. 2006;41(4):227-232. doi.org
- Pashler H, McDaniel M, Rohrer D, Bjork R. Learning Styles: Concepts and Evidence. Psychological Science in the Public Interest. 2008;9(3):105-119. doi.org
